Francesca: Anterior Physeal Arrest w/ Recurvatum Deformity & Shortening

Patient: Francesca
Condition: Lower Limb Deformity (Anterior Physeal Arrest w/ Recurvatum Deformity & Shortening)
Age Range at Time of Treatment: 12 years


Francesca is a competitive level female gymnast who sustained a proximal tibia fracture at the age of 10 after falling off a balance beam and landing incorrectly on her right leg. She was treated at a local emergency room at which point she was sedated and her leg was manipulated into position and placed in a long leg cast for eight weeks. After her cast was removed, she received physical therapy for strengthening for approximately six weeks.

One year and four months after the injury, Francesca was still experiencing intermittent pain in her right knee and was frustrated by her inability to return to gymnastics. She visited a doctor who took x-rays and advised that her knee pain could be resolved with more therapy and a brace. A week after her consultation, Francesca and her mother visited me for a second opinion.


X-rays revealed that the injury to Francesca’s tibia had damaged her growth plate (physis). The injury caused her physis to prematurely close and led to the development of a recurvatum deformity where her right knee bent backwards 16 degrees more than her left knee. An MRI was ordered to further map her right knee’s physeal closure.

Francesca Diagnosis X-ray

X-rays showing recurvatum deformity and unequal lengths.


Francesca Before Surgery#1

Right knee bent backwards 16 degrees more than the left knee.


  • Proximal Tibia Fibular Osteotomy w/ Application of Taylor Spatial Frame

    A small incision was made over the distal third of the fibula, the membrane that covers the surface of the fibula (subperiosteal) was dissected, and the fibula was cut with a saw (osteotomy). The wound was closed in layers, and dry sterile dressings were applied. A pre-constructed Taylor Spatial Frame was then affixed to the tibia and fibula with a wire and five half-pins.

    Francesca After Surgery#1

    Francesca after surgery with her Taylor Spatial Frame in place.

Post Op

Francesca’s deformities were corrected over the course of 17 days as her leg was slowly lengthened and the recurvatum deformity resolved.


Two weeks after surgery, Francesca’s knees had good range of motion and her pin sites were clean with no signs of infection. Her sutures were removed and replaced with steri strips. She began physical therapy for her upper and lower body.

Three weeks after surgery, x-rays of Francesca’s legs revealed that her limbs were of equal length and her right leg was straight. A stabilizing strut was added to the spatial frame and Francesca was permitted to fully bear weight on her leg. I gave her instructions to begin working on full extension of the leg in physical therapy, a prescription for an Exogen machine to be used twice daily, and weaning off any antibiotics.

Francesca Surgery#1 Observation#2 X-ray

X-rays three weeks after surgery showing limbs of equal length and a straight lower right leg.

Francesca Surgery#1 Observation#2

Francesca bearing weight on her leg and being active with her frame.


  • Bilateral Proximal Tibial Epiphysiodesis & Removal of Hardware

    Francesca X-ray Before Removal of Hardware

    Six days before removal of hardware, Francesca’s limbs were of equal length and her corrected recurvatum deformity was mostly healed.

    Three months after the initial surgery, the frame was ready for removal. The procedure began with removing the frame from the right leg while leaving the pins in place. Incisions were then made over the right and left proximal tibia and the physes were removed (epiphysiodesis) from both upper tibias. This was done to prevent a recurrence of the angulation of the leg or one leg growing longer than the other. The pins were then all removed and the sites where the pins had been were cleaned and excess tissue removed. Dry sterile dressings were applied.

Post Op

After surgery, Francesca wore a cam walker fracture boot and wasn’t allowed to run or participate in sports for six weeks.


Two and a half months after surgery, I advised that, any pain or weakness that she was experiencing could be resolved with continued physical therapy and exercise at home. She became stronger and stronger.


Francesca Conclusion X-ray

X-rays showing legs are fully healed, of equal length, and straight.

Francesca was doing well and had full range of motion and good strength in her leg six months after her hardware had been removed. Her osteotomy had fully healed and she was able to return to all of her normal activities including gymnastics.

Download Presentation PDF

Francesca Case Study Presentation

SlideShare Presentation


“My daughter Francesca is a patient of Dr. Feldman’s. We came to Dr. Feldman in March of 2013 after my daughter had broke her leg in November…not really sure what was wrong with her and he diagnosed her that her growth plate had fused after the leg broke and she would need extensive surgery. We weren’t really prepared for that diagnosis but he was very calm and reassured us that everything was going to be ok.

I left that appointment really feeling like it was going to be ok. And every meeting we had from that point up until her surgery we always left calm and reassured. And he was great, the morning of the surgery he was great with us and was great with Francesca. After the surgery we were in the hospital for three days, he came and saw us every day that we were in the hospital.

And he has just been wonderful – our whole experience with the whole staff here, Ella, Dr. Feldman. Our phone calls were returned immediately with any questions that we had. I highly highly recommend Dr. Feldman.”

- Karen (Francesca’s Mom)